How does Windows Server 2008 Backup work?
The new block-level backup infrastructure in Windows Server 2008 (which is also in Windows Vista Business, Enterprise and Ultimate) is aimed at making server recovery fast. Let's discuss how it works from a variety of angles.
Image based backup
For starters, the new WSB is a block-level volume image based solution. As such, it runs appreciably faster than file-level backup solutions as the usual overhead of opening and closing each file to be backed up is not required. As an image based solution, it is also geared towards fast system recovery, going the route that was pioneered by products such as Acronis, Ghost and Backup Exec System Recovery.
The specific implementation that Microsoft has provided has the following characteristics:
- You can only select entire volumes for backup, not individual files and directories.
- The resulting backup file is a VHD file
- The backup is a selective image - not a forensic clone - of the source volumes. This means that things like blank space, the page file, hibernate file, and certain folders are not backed up.
Fast differential images
By default, the backups performed are fast differentials, where only changed blocks are backed up. (Note: Microsoft refers to them as incremental, but we believe differential to be a more accurate term.)
A good way to imagine how this works is by imagining your machine's life disk volumes on the left, the backup device on the right, and an intelligent comparison machine in the middle, transferring blocks across.
The backup is then a "left-right comparison" with the differences getting transferred across, as shown in the diagram.
There are some very important things to note:
- The backup device looks like it always contains the last full backup, even though only changed blocks were transferred
- Restores are easy - like restoring a full backup, and not having to worry about the traditional Full + Incremental + Incremental...
- Successive backups are fast in typical scenarios because only a small percentage of the disk changes on a day to day basis
Automatic disk space management
Another bonus is that you will never run out of disk space caused by the accumulation of previous backups. (Note: Of course, you will run out of space if the total data you're trying to back up exceeds the capacity of the backup device.)
Past versions are automatically discarded as the backup device fills up. This happens automatically.
VSS based file and application backup
The entire backup system is based on VSS, which is used to tell which blocks have changed. The exact way this works has not been published by Microsoft; however from our testing we believe it to be based around using persistent snapshots and comparing differences between the snapshots.
Because the system is based on VSS (unlike some other drive imaging products), it means that it's possible to backup VSS aware applications, like Exchange Server 2007, SQL Server 2005 and SharePoint Services. At the time of the backup, WSB will issue a notification to VSS that a backup is about to start, and in turn, VSS will notify the VSS aware applications to commit their data to disk. This means that the backup will be consistent, and any open databases will have their data committed and in a consistent state.
There are two different restore procedures:
- Bare metal restore - that is, restoring to a new system that does not have an OS already installed on it.
This can be done by booting off the original Windows install DVD, choosing to run the Windows Complete PC Restore (yes - they forgot to rename it to Windows Server Backup restore!) and then following the wizard. For a step by step procedure, please see article "HOWTO: Bare-Metal Restores from Windows Server 2008 Backup" We've also found that we can restore to dissimilar hardware - "Hardware Independent Bare Metal Restores using Windows Server 2008 Backup (wbadmin)"
- Individual file and folder restore - by following the wizards you can restore individual files and folders - "HOWTO: File and Application Restoration from Windows Server 2008 Backup"
Limitations of Windows Server Backup
As with most things that come built-into the operating system, there are limitations in what's built into Windows. Most notably, the monitoring and reporting side is extremely weak, and there are also several gaping holes in terms of hardware support.Monitoring and reporting
- No concept of media rotation strategies
- The wizards do not show
- No such thing as emailing the backup status report
- No way to automatically see what versions of backups are available on the backup device
- The drive letter is removed from backup devices
- No centralized monitoring ability for monitoring large numbers of servers
- Cannot set up automated backups to rdx and REV drives using the Microsoft wizards
- Cannot set up automated backups to NAS using the Microsoft wizards
- Can only select entire volumes to backup, not individual files and folders
- Can only select local volumes to backup, not network shares
These matters are discussed further in the articles on this website. All of these limitations are addressed by the 3rd party product called BackupAssist.
The major functionality available in Windows Server Backup is undoubtedly the hardware independent server restores from bare metal. In previous operating systems, to achieve this, you'd have to spend thousands of dollars on 3rd party imaging solutions. Now, it's free.
However, there are a considerable number of limitations that can only be overcome by extensive scripting and manual scheduling, or by using a 3rd party product like BackupAssist.